Login
Migration Narratives: The SHRAM Blog

Cost of migration: The plight of migration workers

It is well known that majority of the internal migrants are found in the construction industry but its size can be gauged from the fact that it is the largest employer in India after agriculture with around 33 million in its labour pool. Another staggering fact is its contribution to the nations GDP which, at 8-8.5%, is second next to agriculture. Considering its enormous size, one should assume that employment under this sector assures certain amount of security. However the informal natures of job search and employee-employer relations leave workers at the receiving end when it comes to welfare and security.  The problem is more acute since majority of the workers are migrants who are exploited owing to their lack of information of the formal rules governing their employment and providing for security.

Migration from fields to cities in search of employment is not a recent phenomenon but what adds to it is the fact that most of the migrants are farmers, semi-skilled or mostly unskilled and land up in cities in search of livelihood options. This raises the question of the effectiveness of the rural employment generation programs in stopping this internal flow and the resulting exploitation at the destination work place. But that’s a different issue of debate. What needs to be focused on currently is how do to make the resulting environment of the construction workers more humane.

The ‘Invisible’ migrant worker

Household work has never been considered work in India. It has always been the duty of the woman: wife, mother, daughter or sister to do the chores and expect no pay. No wonder then that the domestic worker is so blatantly underpaid and exploited.

Almost 400 million, or 85% of the workforce of the country is in the unorganized sector, mostly comprising of women. These mainly includes migrants coming from tribal areas in search of employment and livelihood. According to United Nations Development Program (UNDP), about 20 million people (mainly women and girls) migrate to Urban Agglomerations (UA) of Mumbai, Delhi and other large cities from the eastern states of Bihar, Chhattisgarh, Jharkhand, Assam and Mizoram (Akter and Deshingkar, 2009).

The largest migration stream in the developing bloc

Since Bangladesh came into existence in 1971, India has been the recipient of its overgrowing population which finds itself out of place and livelihood in the former Muslim nation state.

At present, migration from Bangladesh is a combined result of social, economic, political and environmental factors. However, according to a UN report on Climate Change, the citizens of Bangladesh remain vulnerable to rising sea levels, which could turn out to be the main determinant for large exodus in future.

UN projections indicate that a sea level rise of 0.5 meters could see Bangladesh lose approximately 11 per cent of its land by 2050, which would affect around 15 million people. Climate migration to urban areas, such as Dhaka, has already begun as Bangladeshis flee desertification in the north, and floods and soil degradation caused by rising sea levels in the south.

Trafficking through the Himalayan kingdom

Nepal may be known for its natural beauty and Mount Everest, but there is a dark side to this small, picturesque country. Women and girls are being bought, sold and smuggled across the Nepal-India border.

Statistics vary on the number of Nepalese women who fall prey to traffickers, but social workers in the country estimate that about 200,000 girls and women are working in Indian brothels, with up to 7,000 more arriving every year, says Rekha Rana, co-ordinator of the combating girls’ trafficking project at the Family Planning Association of Nepal(FPAN). Others are trafficked into domestic servitude.

From poor to poorer?

Even as debates on the different measures of poverty levels and poverty lines run their course, there is an uncounted population which is struggling to find its identity. This is the growing numbers of internal migrants of India that are largely invisible.

The total number of migrants as per the census of India, 1971 is 167 million persons, 1981 census 213 million, 1991 census 232 million and 2001 census 315 million.

 

Cash transfer in India-Will it help migrant workers?

The present Government at the Centre has been quite vocal and desperate on launching Conditional Cash Transfer in India. Mr. P.Chidambaram, The Finance Minister of India has termed CCT as a big game changer for fighting corruption and protecting public money. It is claimed that under the regime of CCT (Conditional Cash Transfer), cash will flow directly to the beneficiary without any leakage. However, the only apprehension the government is having is to reaching out to the last mile? The non banking service area is still a huge challenge for the government to transfer DBT (Direct Benefit Transfer). According to  RBI  only 40% of the population in India have access to banking facilities. Out of 6.4 lac villages, the presence of bank branches with full-fledged services is available only in 34000 villages and recently another 73000 villages are covered under Banking Correspondent model.

Policies for migrant workers

In India, many people migrate due to lack of opportunities in their native place. In recent years, a very high rate of internal migration has been witnessed in India. Employment, by far, remains the biggest cause of migration in the country. Maharashtra, Gujarat, the south Indian states and other states in northern parts of the country like Haryana, Punjab and Delhi have become attractive destinations for the migrant population. Rapid urbanisation and industrialisation of these areas have generated more employment opportunities and also created better infrastructure. People migrate to these regions perceiving them as greener pastures.

These migrant workers are vulnerable when they enter new places. They may have to work on low wages and may not have even the basic necessities. There is an urgent need to formulate a planned, long-term strategy to counter the problem. There are many measures taken by the government for the migrants, but these are not reaching the poor migrant workers.

Orissa and Andhra Pradesh to take care of migrant labour

Orissa and Andhra Pradesh area all set to sign an inter-state agreement to take care of migrant labour working in unorganized sectors such as in brick kilns and construction sites. The two State governments, Union government and International Labour Organisation will be part of the institutional mechanism as envisaged under the draft agreement.

The agreement first of its kind in the country, was mooted when reports of Oriya migrant labour being subjected to torture in hand of labour contractors and brick kiln manufacturers in Andhrapradesh came pouring in.